| Google Rating | 4.5 (358 reviews) | Sammataro Pizza | — | Google Places - Sammataro Pizza | Verified |
| Google Reviews | 358 | Sammataro Pizza | — | Google Places - Sammataro Pizza | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro is no secret, but I just tried it and it’s the bes... | — | positive | Best pizza in town. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Don’t catch Sammatarro on a bad day… | — | negative | Best pizza in town. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | First time trying Sammataro today. Definitely one of the bes... | — | positive | Best pizza in town. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro | — | positive | Best restaurant you visited in Austin in 2024? Building my 2025 bucket list. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro on E 12th | — | positive | In Austin for the week, looking for the best Italian food. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | 1. Sammataro (9.0) | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro but their pizza is way too floppy and undercooked. | — | negative | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro is great but I won’t eat there out of principle. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | I'd put All Day head and shoulders above Sammataro | — | negative | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | All day and Sammataro were my fave | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro’s is the best in town. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | still think it's the best pies. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro (8.8): Pricey but good. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro’s is the best in town. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro is the best pizza in the city | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | i liked sammataro (food truck) | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro - Specifically, the Supreme Pizza | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Samorto is good but pricy | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Allday outpaces Sammataro any day of the week | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro was great 2 years ago and then became too inconsis... | — | negative | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammaturo is my favorite | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |