| Award | 0.5 | — | positive | Austin Chronicle Best of Austin 2025 - Critics | Verified |
| Google Rating | 4.8 (150 reviews) | Small’s Pizza | — | Google Places - Small’s Pizza | Verified |
| Google Reviews | 150 | Small’s Pizza | — | Google Places - Small’s Pizza | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Gotta give it to Smalls pizza | — | positive | Best pizza in town. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | People mentioned it after my first comment. Small's. | — | positive | Best pizza in town. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Smalls praised as the only New Haven style pizzeria in Austi... | — | positive | Name your top 5 BEST restaurants in Austin right now? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | 1. Small's Pizza (9.2) | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | You also might want to try Smalls | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | I think Smalls recently closed. | — | neutral | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Smalls is #1 | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | It’s Smalls, AllDay and Pedroso in a big lead. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Smalls has the best pie in Austin. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Smalls is #1 | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | I just discovered them and bookmarked for the anchovy pizza | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Small's might be my only opportunity to try some New Haven s... | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Yes, personally, it’s my new favorite | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Had their anchovy pizza ... too salty for me, the couple bit... | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Smalls is incredible and beats out All Day for me | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Small’s is incredible. Best I’ve had in town by a lot. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | It’s close to my apartment... it’s so freaking good | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | They do slices during the week at lunch so you could try a s... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Their vodka sauce pizza is to die for | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | I agree that Small's is the best. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | def on my list of places to try. Looks like I need to get to... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Agree with small’s 🏆 | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Fr, Smalls is king. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Gonna check out Small’s! Turns out I live 3 mins away | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Smalls pizza has only 4 ratings. You must be the owner or an... | — | negative | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Smalls is legit amazing pizza. Def the best in Austin right ... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Smalls is legit amazing pizza | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | My brain could not process that blob... formatted list with ... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Smalls is the best by far... single best food I’ve had in Au... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |