| Award | 0.35 | — | positive | Austin's Best Restaurants of 2025: Austin American Statesman | Verified |
| Award | 0.35 | — | positive | Austin's Best Restaurants of 2024: Austin American Statesman | Verified |
| Award | 0.2 | — | positive | The 25 Best Restaurants in Austin - Austin Monthly | Verified |
| Award | 0.1 | — | positive | The 38 Best Restaurants in Austin, Winter 2026 -- Eater | Verified |
| Award | 0.2 | — | positive | James Beard 2024 | Verified |
| Google Rating | 4.5 (863 reviews) | — | — | Google Places - Bufalina Due | Verified |
| Google Rating | 4.5 (1202 reviews) | Bufalina | — | Google Places - Bufalina Pizza | Verified |
| Google Reviews | 1202 | Bufalina | — | Google Places - Bufalina Pizza | Verified |
| Google Reviews | 863 | Bufalina Due LLC | — | Google Places - Bufalina Due | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina happy hour is where it’s at. Half price pies and bo... | — | positive | Best pizza in town. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina and DeSano are both great at Neapolitan | — | positive | Best pizza in town. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | the caesar salad at bufalina is the best i've ever had | — | positive | Favorite salad in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Caesar at Bufalina Due | — | positive | Favorite salad in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bibb Salad at Bufalina | — | positive | Favorite salad in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | I would probably take the pizza I had there over bufalina to... | — | positive | The best restaurants in Austin, according to our 2025 food guide | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina stated as favorite pizza with great wine list. | — | positive | Name your top 5 BEST restaurants in Austin right now? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina praised for great pies and happy hour deal. | — | positive | Name your top 5 BEST restaurants in Austin right now? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina | — | positive | Your top 10 restaurants in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina | — | positive | Your top 10 restaurants in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina | — | positive | Your top 10 restaurants in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina | — | positive | Your top 10 restaurants in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | bufalina due | — | positive | Your top 10 restaurants in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | I love Bufalina, delicious wood fire pizza | — | positive | In Austin for the week, looking for the best Italian food. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | And handmade pasta!! | — | positive | In Austin for the week, looking for the best Italian food. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Happy hour is half off all bottles of wine and pizzas. | — | positive | In Austin for the week, looking for the best Italian food. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | This is the way | — | positive | In Austin for the week, looking for the best Italian food. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina is some of my favorite pizza in the world. | — | positive | In Austin for the week, looking for the best Italian food. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina is great pizza | — | positive | In Austin for the week, looking for the best Italian food. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | 2. Bufalina Due (9.0) | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina ... are solid choices | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina is a personal favorite for wine as well. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina is still the queen for Neapolitan style | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina has delicious pizza but the last one I had was so r... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina and Little Deli are solid choices, though! | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina is a personal favorite for wine as well. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina is still the queen for Neapolitan style | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina has delicious pizza but the last one I had was so r... | — | neutral | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina (East Austin) bar seats are good for solo eating an... | — | positive | Best Wine Bars and Cocktail Bars for a solo business Traveler. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | DeSano and Buffalina | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Show Me Pizza and Bufalina are doing things right | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Buffalina Due. Go for happy hour when pizza is half off. The... | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | bufalina is gas | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | I argue it’s better than Bufalina | — | negative | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Bufalina’s mushroom pie is my hyper fixation rn | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | I've tried Pedrosos, Bufalina Due, and Allday... All are ama... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | I literally went to Bufalina to get a pizza after. | — | positive | What is the best tasting menu in Austin? | Verified |