| Google Rating | 4.3 (332 reviews) | Favorite Pizza | — | Google Places - Favorite Pizza | Verified |
| Google Reviews | 332 | Favorite Pizza | — | Google Places - Favorite Pizza | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Sammataro and Favorite are my top 2 followed by Little Deli | — | positive | Best pizza in town. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite for NY style | — | positive | Best pizza in town. | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite Pizza right next door has the same exact Caesar sal... | — | positive | Favorite salad in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Pizza: Favorite Pizza | — | positive | Your top 10 restaurants in Austin? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | One that hasn’t been mentioned is Favorite Pizza, solid slic... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite was an oily mess. | — | negative | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | How would you rate Favorite Pizza? | — | neutral | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite Pizza is a good one too for NY slices! | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite Pizza is a good one too for NY slices! | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite on 6th next to Sammy’s ... authentic NYC pizza. | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | $22 for a large cheese/pepperoni AND a pitcher of beer | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite is terrible... devoid of any flavor or taste whatso... | — | negative | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite Pizza | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite Pizza on 6th for NYC pizza | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | My favorite pizza | — | positive | Your favorite pizza?? | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Favorite Pizza is far better than Salvation. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Maybe just because I live right next to it but I love Favori... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | Try Favorite Pizza, and get a fresh pie not a slice. | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |
| Reddit Mention | They’ve got a sharper, more complex cheese than All Day... | — | positive | Austin Pizza Rankings v2 | Verified |